We would love to hear your feedback. Please leave your reviews here. Much appreciated!
I tried That Guy’s for the first time a few weeks ago. I am always hesitant, because it seems there isn’t a place that makes good pizza like I remember from back east. I am SO glad I took a chance! The pizza was phenomenal, but my biggest kudos are for the wings. Holy Cow they are the most delicious morsels I have ever tasted.
Love this place!!!!
We are having a That Guys Pizza withdraws. Do you deliver to Show Low…
We love That Guy’s!
Amazing food, great service!!
I tried a slice and it was delicious!
Love that place. Good food, great people!!
I had the Buckthorn calzone–it was excellent!
Great owners tooo.
My son loves there chicken Alfredo.
Well kellen, we took your advice. It was sooooooo awesome!!!!!!
Will you make me a pizza sub and not tell my trainer?
We love your pizza!
The spaghetti & meatballs is great and so is the buckhorn calzone don’t forget the caloni and they deliver!
had saghetti and sausage last night.. Delicious
Ate there Monday….thanks for the recommendation Kellen!
The pizza was very good!
Great pizza AND great pasta
Love That Guy’s Pizza!
great restaurant … wishing you all a great success here in ftn hills…and hopefully another location also.. maybe bigger for dining in with for tables
Another reason to love That Guy’s Pizza! Our son is also high functioning autistic and we appreciate the trust his employer places in him!
I love this sandwich from that guys!!
Went on Saturday! Very pleased! Great food, price and people!
Have not had the opportunity to stop in, but I have heard only good things and look forward to it. I think the 2 Slices for $4.00 is a great Deal!!!!
We tried this place last weekend. Best lasagna in Fountain Hills!
Haven’t tried the lasagna yet but will next time we eat there.
My favorite is the Italian Sub at That Guys Pizza. The Tiramisu is also delicious to!
The pizza was really good the staff were very kind and friendly I recommend to everyone!
loved my lunch special! pizza was perfect just wish you would move to a place with more parking and a bigger dining area! keep up the great work!
Love everything about this pizza place. Great food and friendly staff.
We love this place! Pasta and salad are our favorites here! The owners are really sweet too!
Let me tell you… I have had many many many pizzas in my life, but this was definitely one of the best. We will definitely be returning. Thank you
Great pizza and really nice people that made me feel comfortable and respected..
Great pizza, great price and great customer service.
Fabulous Calzones !!! Can’t wait to try other items.
Chicken Pesto Calzone
Fresh Homeade Tiramasu.
Tried it last night The pizza & wings where awesome
Pros- I love their pizza, it’s been a long time since I’ve had a great slice of pizza. Great pizza, love the crispy crust , good sauce, perfect amount of cheese. Put it all together and you have a tasty authentic New York pizza!! Calzones are huge, looking forward to trying one. Pizza by the slice, big slice too. The price is right. Friendly staff. Clean and comfortable place.
Cons- Small parking lot,
So glad to see Redendos gone. It was not like New York pizza. If you like New York pizza, this is the place to go. It is the best in the valley. I live now in Payson and always look forward to having their awesome pizza when in town. Am In town now, heading home tomorrow. Will stop by for a meatball sub and a pizza to go. Yum! Good prices also.
Sad to see Redendos go as well but this place is just as good, if not better! There are great deals on pizza, appetizers etc. The wings are also AMAZING. Unlike other places that drench their wings in hot sauce, they come already spicy with no sauce which makes them super crispy and the meat is so tender! This is definitely my new go to pizza joint.
Great french dip sandwich had to take another home to go also teramasu a must
That Guy’s Pizza – Delicious food made with quality ingredients and efficient service with a smile. Welcome to Fountain Hills!
NY quality pizza. City atmosphere and friendly staff. Love it every time…(even the salads!)
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
Notify me of new posts by email.